tech

Linus Torvalds to critics of AI coding in Linux: "Fork it. Or just walk away."

Creator says he will “very loudly ignore” those arguing for a ban on AI tools.

Linus Torvalds to critics of AI coding in Linux: "Fork it. Or just walk away."

TL;DR

  • Linus Torvalds supports the use of AI coding tools in the Linux kernel.
  • He stated that critics of AI in Linux should fork the project or leave.
  • Torvalds believes AI is a useful tool, comparing its imperfections to those of human coders.
  • A debate arose regarding the use of Sashiko, an AI system that identifies bugs but also generates false positives.
  • The Software Freedom Conservancy's stance supporting rejection of LLM-gen-AI systems was cited.
  • Torvalds argued against forcing projects to avoid LLM-generated code.
  • Studies on AI's impact on developer productivity show mixed results, with recent findings suggesting increased speed.
  • Torvalds himself has experimented with AI tools for personal projects.
  • Some in the open source community, like the developer behind jqwik, have implemented measures against AI tools.
  • A legal consideration is that LLM output may not be copyrightable and thus not licenseable under traditional open-source licenses without significant human input.